The Burgee Affair


An Outrage Against Sovereignty

Concerning the unlawful appropriation of Club colours, a regrettable incident in the South West of England, and the apparent failure of international maritime law to protect the rights of gentlemen.

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club has always maintained that membership is a privilege, not an entitlement.

It is a distinction which the modern world, in its tiresome enthusiasm for equality, accessibility and the wholesale dismantling of established standards, appears increasingly incapable of understanding.

The Club is not a public institution. It does not solicit applications, advertise its attractions or concern itself unduly with the aspirations of those unfortunate enough to find themselves excluded from its company.

Indeed, the Committee has long considered that the principal virtue of a private club lies not in the people who belong to it, but in the vastly greater number who do not.

It was therefore with a mixture of astonishment and profound displeasure that reports recently reached the Committee of an unidentified vessel in the South West of England displaying what appeared unmistakably to be the burgee of the BSYC.

The vessel was not known to the Club.

Its owner was not a member.

And, most damningly of all, the burgee was being flown incorrectly.

An outrage against the sovereignty of the Club had occurred.

 

A most unfortunate discovery

The precise circumstances of the discovery need not concern us here. It is sufficient to record that a vessel having no legitimate association with the BSYC was observed displaying the Club’s distinctive colours in a manner wholly inconsistent with established yachting practice.

Initially, an innocent explanation was considered. Perhaps a member had acquired a new yacht without informing the Committee. Perhaps the vessel had been borrowed, or the colours temporarily entrusted to a fellow yachtsman for some entirely respectable purpose.

Such explanations, though unlikely, were not beyond contemplation.

However, closer examination revealed a far more disturbing fact.

The burgee was not flying from the masthead.

The significance of this observation cannot be overstated.

Under the Club’s regulations, the BSYC burgee is to be flown from the masthead upon a suitable pigstick, or, in the case of a motor vessel, from an appropriately dignified mast provided for that purpose.

This is not a recommendation. It is not an invitation to personal interpretation.

It is a fundamental principle of the established nautical order.

The display of a Club burgee from a spreader, backstay, guardrail or other improvised appendage is not an expression of individuality. It is a public confession of ignorance.

A gentleman may occasionally be forgiven an error of navigation, a poorly executed tack or even an unfortunate choice of luncheon companion.

He cannot be forgiven for not knowing where to fly his burgee.

 

The unmistakable mark of an impostor

The Committee has given considerable thought to the motives of the offender.

It is possible that the individual simply admired the Club’s colours and, in a moment of misplaced enthusiasm, decided to acquire them.

This would be understandable.

The BSYC has, despite its best efforts to discourage unnecessary attention, acquired a reputation for distinction which naturally attracts the admiration of those outside its ranks.

Throughout history, men of modest standing have sought to improve their social circumstances through association with their betters.

Such ambitions are not, in themselves, objectionable.

Their fulfilment is quite another matter.

The possession of a Club burgee does not confer membership, any more than the purchase of a crown entitles its wearer to occupy the throne.

More importantly, the offender’s ignorance of burgee etiquette provides conclusive evidence of imposture.

No properly admitted member of the BSYC could conceivably be unaware of the correct manner in which the Club’s colours are to be displayed.

It follows, therefore, that an individual flying them incorrectly cannot be a member.

The reasoning is, in the Committee’s view, unassailable.

Indeed, it renders any consultation of the membership register largely unnecessary.

One may counterfeit a burgee. One cannot counterfeit a gentleman.

 

The decline of flag etiquette

It is a regrettable feature of modern yachting that the proper use of flags has increasingly become a matter of indifference.

One encounters ensigns of improbable dimensions, courtesy flags hoisted in entirely inappropriate positions, and decorative pennants whose origins and significance appear unknown even to those displaying them.

The modern yachtsman, having purchased a vessel equipped with electronic navigation, hydraulic conveniences and an extraordinary number of cupholders, frequently imagines that he has thereby acquired the entirety of the knowledge necessary to command her.

He has not.

There was a time when a gentleman entering harbour understood instinctively which colours were to be flown, where they belonged and what obligations accompanied them.

The ensign proclaimed nationality. The courtesy flag acknowledged the waters of a foreign sovereign. The burgee identified a yacht’s club affiliation and, by extension, the standing of those aboard her.

These were not matters of decoration.

They were the visible language of a maritime civilisation, understood by yachtsmen whose education extended somewhat beyond the operation of a touchscreen.

Today, alas, flags are increasingly treated as accessories, selected according to colour, convenience or their compatibility with the upholstery.

A yacht-club burgee is not bunting.

Nor is it a souvenir of an agreeable afternoon spent drinking at the bar of an establishment to which one does not belong.

It is a mark of membership, and membership is the consequence of admission, not acquisition.

That so elementary a distinction should require explanation is itself a damning indictment of the age.

 

An affront to sovereignty

The implications of the affair extend far beyond the improper display of a piece of cloth.

If an individual may simply appropriate the colours of a distinguished yacht club, what then becomes of the institution’s sovereignty?

What purpose is served by membership rules, committees, elections, traditions and the considerable effort expended upon excluding unsuitable candidates?

The Committee considers the matter comparable, in principle, to the unlawful assumption of an ambassadorial flag, the wearing of decorations to which one is not entitled, or the occupation of a reserved table at a respectable luncheon establishment.

These are not trivial offences.

They strike at the foundations of an ordered society.

It is therefore astonishing that international maritime law appears to offer so little explicit protection to the sovereignty of yacht-club burgees.

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, despite its considerable length and evident ambition, appears to have devoted an entirely inadequate proportion of its attention to the matter.

The Committee can only presume that this omission arose through oversight.

It has been suggested that the matter might be referred to the European Union, although the Committee has little appetite for discovering how many regulations, working groups and mandatory consultations would be required before Brussels could agree upon which end of a pigstick was uppermost.

The Club has therefore resolved, at least for the present, to defend its own colours.

 

Progress, whether required or not

The incident is symptomatic of a wider and altogether more depressing phenomenon.

We live in an age possessed by the curious conviction that everything must be improved, particularly those things which have functioned perfectly satisfactorily for several centuries.

Traditions must be modernised. Institutions must become accessible. Established practices must be reviewed, reconsidered and ultimately replaced by arrangements which are invariably more complicated and seldom better.

The question of whether improvement is actually required rarely seems to arise.

The maritime world has suffered particularly from this affliction.

Yachts have become floating apartment buildings. Navigation has been entrusted to screens. Seamanship is increasingly mistaken for proficiency in operating electronic equipment, and the once respectable yacht club is gradually being transformed into a species of leisure centre.

Even the simple business of flying a flag, governed for generations by established custom, is now apparently considered an opportunity for personal expression.

The Committee regards this with profound disappointment.

There is nothing inherently virtuous about novelty.

A practice does not become obsolete merely because it is old, nor does an institution become better simply because it has abandoned the standards upon which it was founded.

Indeed, the Committee is increasingly persuaded that the principal achievement of modern progress has been to render straightforward matters unnecessarily complicated, while making genuinely important matters appear optional.

It was once sufficient for a gentleman to know his club, know his colours and know where to fly them.

Today, apparently, even this is asking too much.

 

On the appropriate consequences

The question of sanctions has naturally occupied much of the Committee’s attention.

A simple request that the offending burgee be removed was considered manifestly inadequate.

Several more appropriate measures were contemplated.

These included the immediate suspension of reciprocal hospitality privileges, whether or not such privileges had ever been granted; notification of the offender’s commodore, should he belong to an institution sufficiently respectable to possess one; and a demand for a formal written apology upon suitably heavy stationery.

One member proposed that the offending burgee be surrendered and ceremonially destroyed.

Another suggested that the vessel concerned be prohibited from approaching any yacht flying the legitimate colours of the BSYC.

A particularly vigorous contribution called for the establishment of an International Court of Yacht Club Heraldry, with jurisdiction over all cases of unauthorised burgee display.

This proposal attracted considerable enthusiasm, especially when it was suggested that the Court might be established in The Hague, thereby lending the proceedings an appropriate degree of continental solemnity.

The Committee has not ruled out the possibility.

It is, however, understood that the establishment of an international tribunal may require a budget, permanent staff and the occasional journey to the Netherlands.

There are limits to what even the BSYC is prepared to endure in defence of civilisation.

 

The Inspector-General of Club Colours

In the meantime, the Committee has resolved to consider the appointment of an Inspector-General of Club Colours.

The office would be responsible for identifying unauthorised displays of the BSYC burgee, investigating suspected cases of impersonation and recommending suitable disciplinary or diplomatic measures.

It has been pointed out that this proposal bears an unfortunate resemblance to the sort of unnecessary bureaucracy which the Club has traditionally condemned.

The comparison is entirely without merit.

Whereas modern bureaucracies exist principally to interfere with the lawful enjoyment of life, the Inspector-General would exist to preserve the established privileges of those properly entitled to enjoy it.

The distinction should be obvious to any reasonable person.

It is anticipated that the office would carry considerable prestige, entail very few actual duties and provide an entirely satisfactory justification for the appointment of another flag officer.

The Committee regards this as a most efficient arrangement.

 

The preservation of distinction

There is, of course, a certain satisfaction to be derived from the affair.

That an individual should wish to associate himself with the BSYC, despite possessing neither the invitation nor the qualifications necessary to do so, is perhaps the most sincere compliment the Club could receive.

Imitation has always been a consequence of distinction.

The established institutions of British society have long endured the attentions of pretenders, social climbers and others who imagine that the outward appearance of belonging might serve as a substitute for the genuine article.

The BSYC can hardly expect to escape the same fate.

Nevertheless, there is a difference between admiration and appropriation.

The modern world has become distressingly reluctant to acknowledge this distinction.

We are repeatedly informed that everything should be accessible, that every institution must broaden its appeal and that the preservation of exclusive privileges is somehow incompatible with the requirements of a progressive society.

The Committee takes a different view.

Not every door must be opened.

Not every tradition must be explained.

And not every burgee may be flown by anyone who happens to fancy its colours.

There is considerable merit in preserving institutions which make demands upon their members, maintain their own standards and decline to apologise for their existence.

Indeed, the Committee has long held that the principal problem with the modern world is not that it contains too many exclusive institutions, but that it contains far too few.

The BSYC intends to remain among them.

 

A final pronouncement

The Committee therefore reminds all yachtsmen that the BSYC burgee is a mark of membership, not an ornament to be purchased, borrowed or casually appropriated.

Its proper place is at the masthead, upon a suitable pigstick, or upon an appropriate mast in the case of a motor vessel.

Its display elsewhere shall be regarded as evidence of nautical ignorance, and where displayed by a vessel not affiliated with the Club, as an act of imposture.

Members are encouraged to remain vigilant and to report suspected infringements to the appropriate flag officer, preferably before luncheon.

The offending vessel in the South West of England is strongly advised to remove the unauthorised colours and reflect upon the seriousness of its conduct.

The Club does not ordinarily seek confrontation.

Nor does it particularly welcome correspondence from persons with whom it has no wish to associate.

Nevertheless, where the sovereignty of its colours is concerned, the Committee is prepared to make an exception.

For while a gentleman may sail beneath many flags, he may only fly the burgee of a club to which he belongs.

And if he does not know where to fly it, he would probably not have been invited to join in the first place.

Shopping Basket