On the regrettable consequences of permitting the general public to operate motor vessels
Concerning the curious hydrodynamics of the modern powerboat, the distinction between courtesy and competence, and the enduring merits of exclusivity.
The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club has long maintained that the privilege of taking to the water ought to be accompanied by at least a rudimentary understanding of what one is doing.
This is not, the Committee feels obliged to point out, an especially demanding proposition.
An individual intending to navigate a vessel might reasonably be expected to possess some appreciation of seamanship, navigation, meteorology and the elementary laws of physics governing the passage of a hull through water.
Such knowledge was once considered an essential prerequisite of yachting.
Today, alas, it appears increasingly optional.
The modern pleasure-boat industry has succeeded in placing vessels of considerable power into the hands of individuals whose principal qualifications are a willingness to sign a finance agreement and an ability to operate a touchscreen.
The consequences are visible upon almost every popular stretch of inland water.
Nowhere is this more apparent than in the apparently charitable, but frequently disastrous, behaviour of the modern powerboat owner when confronted with a sailing yacht or rowing boat.
An unfortunate act of consideration
The scene will be familiar to anyone who has spent a pleasant afternoon sailing or rowing upon a river.
A motorboat approaches at speed, comfortably established upon the plane, its hull skimming efficiently across the surface.
Its occupant notices a smaller, slower craft ahead.
Perhaps a sailing yacht, proceeding gracefully under canvas. Perhaps a rowing shell, whose occupants are engaged in the admirable pursuit of propelling themselves through water without the assistance of several hundred horsepower.
The powerboat driver, wishing to demonstrate consideration, reduces his speed.
An apparently commendable gesture.
Unfortunately, he reduces it by precisely the wrong amount.
Rather than slowing to a modest displacement speed, the vessel settles into that most objectionable condition somewhere between efficient planing and sensible progress through the water.
The bow rises. The stern digs in. The engine labours.
And behind the vessel develops a mountainous procession of water, sufficient to suggest that a minor geological event has occurred beneath the surface.
The unsuspecting oarsman, who had moments earlier been enjoying an entirely agreeable afternoon, finds himself confronted by a succession of waves of quite unnecessary proportions.
The sailing yacht heels indignantly, her sails flog, and the crew abandon whatever useful activity they had been undertaking in order to contend with the consequences of another man’s courtesy.
The motorboat driver, meanwhile, proceeds slowly onwards, secure in the knowledge that he has behaved with exemplary consideration.
He may even offer a friendly wave.
The Committee regards this final gesture as particularly offensive.
A brief excursion into linear wave theory
The explanation, of course, is not especially mysterious.
Linear wave theory provides a useful starting point for understanding the propagation of surface waves and the relationship between wavelength, frequency, water depth and wave speed.
A conventional planing powerboat, however, introduces further complications, not least the hydrodynamic resistance and displacement of water as the hull moves through the various regimes of operation.
At low displacement speeds, she may proceed with relatively little disturbance.
As power is increased, however, she approaches the limits of efficient displacement operation. The bow rises, the stern settles and the vessel begins expending a remarkable quantity of energy in the production of waves.
The resistance increases substantially as she approaches the transition to planing.
At last, with sufficient power, the hull climbs onto the plane. Less of her remains immersed, and the pattern of wash changes accordingly.
For many planing craft, the greatest waves are generated not at their normal cruising speed, but during that unhappy intermediate condition in which the vessel is attempting to climb over her own bow wave.
It is a principle which ought to be familiar to anyone entrusted with the command of such a boat.
The correct response when approaching smaller craft is therefore not to reduce speed by some arbitrary amount which merely feels considerate.
It is to understand the characteristics of one’s vessel and act accordingly.
Where conditions, regulations, separation and safety permit, a vessel already properly established upon the plane may produce considerably less wash than one wallowing along just below it.
Otherwise, the considerate skipper should slow decisively to a genuinely low-wash displacement speed, leaving ample room and observing the effect of his passage.
The essential point is not that speed is inherently virtuous.
It is that the quantity of disturbance caused by a vessel cannot always be judged by the apparent moderation of its speed.
The Committee accepts that this requires a modest appreciation of hydrodynamics.
It nevertheless considers such knowledge rather more useful than the ability to adjust the colour of one’s underwater lighting from a mobile telephone.
The difference between courtesy and competence
There is a broader lesson here.
The powerboat driver genuinely believes himself to be acting considerately.
His intentions may be entirely honourable.
Yet the consequences of his intervention are considerably worse than those which might have arisen had he understood his vessel and exercised proper judgement.
This is one of the great difficulties of the modern world.
Good intentions are increasingly treated as an adequate substitute for competence.
They are not.
A courteous incompetent remains incompetent, however agreeable his manner.
The Committee has encountered this phenomenon in numerous walks of life.
There are motorists who stop unexpectedly in the middle of the road to permit another vehicle to proceed, thereby creating confusion where previously there was none.
There are hotel architects who provide enormous jacuzzis in every bedroom while neglecting the apparently trivial business of supplying coffee before seven in the morning.
And there are powerboat owners who, in their eagerness to display consideration towards fellow water users, succeed in transferring a substantial proportion of the river into their wake.
The underlying error is identical.
The individual wishes to do the right thing without first acquiring the knowledge necessary to know what the right thing is.
The Committee considers this a most unsatisfactory arrangement.
Further consequences of nautical ignorance
It is, of course, difficult to contemplate the individual responsible for such an extraordinary display of wash generation without wondering what other calamities he might inflict upon the unsuspecting public.
One imagines him approaching a crowded marina with considerable confidence, entirely unaware that a vessel’s momentum does not disappear merely because its engine has been placed in neutral.
Having misjudged his approach, he applies a generous quantity of reverse thrust, directing an impressive torrent of water towards a neighbouring yacht whose owner had been enjoying a peaceful afternoon upon the stern.
The resulting disturbance is attributed to an unexpected gust of wind.
Later, the same skipper may find himself puzzled by the reluctance of his vessel to turn sharply at speed, having assumed that the laws of vehicle dynamics apply to boats in precisely the same manner as they do to his motor car.
The discovery that water offers rather less lateral resistance than a well-surfaced road is made at considerable expense.
There is also the matter of anchoring.
One can readily picture our enthusiastic motorist arriving in a crowded anchorage, selecting a position of apparently excellent convenience and deploying his anchor with little consideration for wind, tide, swinging circles or the unfortunate vessels already occupying the surrounding water.
He retires below, entirely satisfied with his arrangements.
Some hours later, the owners of three neighbouring yachts find themselves unexpectedly participating in a collective exercise in ground-tackle management.
The Committee would also be interested to observe his approach to mooring lines.
The widespread tendency to regard a line as adequately secured merely because it has been wound repeatedly around a cleat is one of the more depressing developments in modern seamanship.
Knots, it seems, have become another of those traditional skills which the contemporary consumer considers unnecessary.
Perhaps most alarming, however, is the prospect of such an individual encountering a navigation mark.
The established system of buoys, lights and shapes represents centuries of accumulated maritime experience, reduced to a language sufficiently straightforward to be understood by almost anyone prepared to learn it.
Yet one suspects that our unfortunate skipper would regard the red and green marks chiefly as decorative features of the waterway, their practical significance remaining a matter for speculation.
Indeed, the Committee finds it difficult to believe that such ignorance can be confined exclusively to the water.
One is inevitably led to wonder how the individual concerned conducts himself in other aspects of life.
Does he, for instance, possess the elementary judgement necessary to distinguish between a red and a white wine glass? Can he operate a dishwasher without first consulting an instructional video? Is he among those unfortunate motorists who believe that the rear fog lamp should be illuminated whenever the weather becomes vaguely disagreeable?
The possibilities are deeply troubling.
One imagines him arriving at a respectable restaurant and immediately requesting the Wi-Fi password, before enquiring whether the chef might accommodate a series of personal preferences wholly incompatible with the cuisine being served.
Perhaps he is the sort of person who applauds when an aeroplane lands, stands immediately upon reaching the terminal despite the seatbelt sign remaining illuminated, and then expresses astonishment that the baggage has not yet appeared upon the carousel.
At home, he may well be responsible for the sort of domestic calamities which the Committee prefers not to contemplate. A washing machine loaded with sufficient enthusiasm to require structural reinforcement. A thermostat adjusted repeatedly in the belief that setting it to thirty degrees will cause the house to warm more quickly. A perfectly serviceable bottle of Champagne subjected to the indignity of being opened with a corkscrew.
One shudders to imagine his approach to the preparation of a gin and tonic.
Does he understand the function of ice? Has he encountered the concept of a suitable measure? Might he, in an excess of misplaced innovation, consider cucumber an appropriate garnish without first establishing whether the gin in question warrants such treatment?
More serious still is the possibility that he may possess opinions.
Indeed, it seems entirely conceivable that an individual so thoroughly unacquainted with the elementary principles of wave generation might nevertheless feel himself qualified to pronounce upon matters of economics, engineering, foreign affairs and the proper administration of the country.
The Committee has observed that ignorance in one field does not invariably discourage confidence in another.
Quite the contrary.
There is a particular class of modern individual whose certainty appears to increase in direct proportion to his unfamiliarity with the subject under discussion.
The Committee naturally excludes its own members from this observation.
Their opinions, however forcefully expressed and occasionally contradictory, are founded upon a combination of experience, intellectual curiosity and the considerable wisdom accumulated through years of distinguished club membership.
The distinction is fundamental.
It is, of course, possible that the offending powerboat owner is in every other respect a competent, thoughtful and thoroughly agreeable person.
He may be an excellent cook, a devoted family man, a distinguished professional and an accomplished conversationalist.
The Committee readily acknowledges this possibility.
It simply considers the available evidence insufficient to justify so charitable a conclusion.
On the merits of exclusivity
It is at this point that the discussion inevitably turns to exclusivity.
The BSYC has never concealed its conviction that exclusivity is among the more beneficial features of a properly ordered society.
This position is frequently misunderstood.
We are assured, with increasing regularity, that every activity must become accessible, every institution welcoming and every privilege available to anyone who expresses an interest.
The Committee finds this curious.
Certain activities require knowledge, judgement and experience.
Flying an aeroplane, performing surgery, navigating a yacht and preparing a proper soufflé are not undertakings which benefit from the wholesale abandonment of established standards.
One would not ordinarily entrust the controls of an aircraft to an individual simply because he admired the colour of its upholstery.
Yet the modern leisure industry appears to consider that the purchase of an expensive motorboat is sufficient evidence of its owner’s capacity to operate it.
The Committee is not persuaded.
Exclusivity, properly understood, need not be concerned with social standing or the possession of a suitable blazer.
Though the Club naturally recognises the considerable merits of the latter.
Its more serious purpose is the preservation of standards.
There is value in institutions which expect their members to know something, to conduct themselves appropriately and to acquire the judgement necessary to participate in a particular activity.
A yacht club ought to be a place where seamanship is understood, traditions are respected and ignorance is corrected before it becomes a public nuisance.
Membership should represent rather more than the ability to pay a subscription.
The Committee has occasionally been accused of snobbery for expressing this view.
It considers the accusation substantially correct, though hardly persuasive.
The unfortunate distinction between owning and knowing
A recurring difficulty of the modern age is the confusion between ownership and mastery.
One may purchase the finest racing bicycle in existence without acquiring the ability to ride it competently.
One may own an extraordinary motor car without understanding the principles of vehicle dynamics.
And one may acquire a magnificent yacht without possessing the judgement necessary to bring her safely into harbour.
These are distinctions which ought to be obvious.
Yet modern commerce has devoted considerable energy to obscuring them.
The purchaser is encouraged to believe that the acquisition of sophisticated equipment constitutes an achievement in itself.
The actual acquisition of skill, experience and judgement is relegated to an optional extra.
The Committee regrets this development.
For the serious yachtsman, the pleasures of sailing are inseparable from the knowledge required to practise it well.
The understanding of wind and tide, the balancing of a hull, the setting of sails, the interpretation of weather and the quiet satisfaction of a manoeuvre properly executed are among the principal rewards of the sport.
It is precisely because these things demand effort that their mastery is worthwhile.
To remove the requirement for understanding is not necessarily to improve the experience.
It may simply diminish it.
The Committee is therefore inclined to the view that the democratisation of an activity, however agreeable in principle, is not invariably accompanied by an improvement in its standards.
There are occasions when a modest barrier to entry performs a useful service.
Particularly when the alternative is an individual in a fifty-thousand-pound motorboat attempting to tow half the river behind him.
The yacht club as the last refuge
Fortunately, there remain institutions in which such distinctions are still understood.
The properly constituted yacht club is among the finest of them.
Wherever a yachtsman may find himself, from the waters of the Mediterranean to the harbours of northern Europe, the sight of an established clubhouse remains a source of considerable reassurance.
Beyond its gates may lie the noise, vulgarity and general confusion of the modern leisure industry.
Within, one may reasonably expect to find a bar, a collection of well-maintained trophies, a few comfortable chairs and several yachtsmen willing to explain, at considerable length, precisely how everyone else is doing things incorrectly.
The Committee considers this one of the great advantages of the international yachting establishment.
The yacht club preserves a community founded not merely upon the ownership of boats, but upon a common appreciation of seamanship, tradition and the proper conduct of life afloat.
It is a refuge from the madding crowd.
A place where one may escape the apparent determination of the wider world to substitute enthusiasm for expertise, convenience for judgement and possession for accomplishment.
The conversation may occasionally become heated.
The opinions expressed may be contradictory.
And the company may contain individuals whose own seamanship would not necessarily survive the scrutiny they so enthusiastically apply to others.
These are regrettable but familiar characteristics of club life.
The Committee sees no reason to interfere with them.
Indeed, the BSYC has long maintained that its members possess an almost unlimited right to criticise the conduct of other yachtsmen, provided that their own shortcomings are discussed only in private and preferably after dinner.
A final observation
The Committee does not propose that motorboats should be abolished.
Such a measure would be unnecessarily severe, particularly as several members own perfectly agreeable examples themselves.
Nor does it suggest that every powerboat owner is ignorant of the principles governing his vessel.
There remain many excellent motor yachtsmen whose competence, courtesy and understanding of the sea command the Club’s wholehearted respect.
The objection is not to power.
It is to ignorance.
And more particularly, to ignorance masquerading as consideration.
A properly handled motorboat is a fine thing. A poorly handled one is an expensive means of inconveniencing everyone within several hundred yards.
The Committee therefore urges those unfamiliar with the principles of hull resistance, wave formation and planing to acquire a little knowledge before next taking to the water.
They may find that their vessels behave rather better than expected.
Their neighbours will certainly appreciate the improvement.
And should they remain uncertain as to the appropriate course of action, they are encouraged to consult an experienced yachtsman.
Such individuals are generally easy to identify.
They are frequently to be found in yacht clubs, wearing blazers, expressing strong opinions and explaining why things were better in the past.
The Committee acknowledges that these characteristics do not provide an infallible guarantee of competence.
They are, however, an excellent starting point.
For while almost anybody may acquire a boat, it remains the particular distinction of a yachtsman to know what to do with one.
And if the Club may be permitted one final observation:
It is an immutable fact that yachtsmen generally do things properly. Where they do not, they are at least sufficiently well acquainted with the rules to know which ones they are breaking.
By order of the Committee