On the Clearing of Barriers

On the Clearing of Barriers


A man walks down a road.

He is an extremely well educated and intelligent man.

He has many qualifications and is regarded highly by his peers.

He is strong, being in early middle age, and carries his strength judiciously.

In his time on earth, he has achieved many things and improved many people’s lives.

He is confident, enigmatic and kind.

The man reaches a gate, which bars his passage along the road. Looking past the gate he sees that the road continues as before, there is no apparent reason for the existence of the gate.

The gate bears a sign, on which, in archaic and convoluted language, writing indicates that the pedestrian should use a small path to the side of the road and re-join the main thoroughfare via this passage shortly.

The gate is an affront to the man, it represents a barrier to the rapid passage of the public, what right does the gate have to exist. The man looks around the gate for an explanation but finds none.

An old man, close to his final years, sitting in his garden next to the road sees the younger man inspecting the gate and calls out to him. In the ensuing conversation the old man explains that the gate has always been there, that his grandfather remembered its construction, that it was a necessary and important gate.

Our protagonist is unconvinced, the old man can give no clear reason for the continued existence of the gate and he has seen first hand the superstitions and carelessness that his forebears exhibited. Ending the conversation he strides off and begins his assault on this contravention of the maxim of progress. He rallies the support that he has built upon his previous achievements, he organises and argues and succeeds in convincing enough people that the gate should be torn down.

The great day arrives and the gate is removed and burnt, for there is no reason to remember old mistakes, surely it is embarrassing that the oversight has remained for so long.

The man continues unhindered down the road and the hubbub dies away.

The next day, a young child wanders down the road, the child passes the point where the gate once stood and are hit by a train as it crosses the road.

An astute reader will have recognised it already, however, for those less well read, these thoughts are most intelligently explored in G.K. Chesterton’s fable about a fence.

Of Wash, Wave Theory and the Uninitiated

Of Wash, Wave Theory and the Uninitiated


On the regrettable consequences of permitting the general public to operate motor vessels

Concerning the curious hydrodynamics of the modern powerboat, the distinction between courtesy and competence, and the enduring merits of exclusivity.

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club has long maintained that the privilege of taking to the water ought to be accompanied by at least a rudimentary understanding of what one is doing.

This is not, the Committee feels obliged to point out, an especially demanding proposition.

An individual intending to navigate a vessel might reasonably be expected to possess some appreciation of seamanship, navigation, meteorology and the elementary laws of physics governing the passage of a hull through water.

Such knowledge was once considered an essential prerequisite of yachting.

Today, alas, it appears increasingly optional.

The modern pleasure-boat industry has succeeded in placing vessels of considerable power into the hands of individuals whose principal qualifications are a willingness to sign a finance agreement and an ability to operate a touchscreen.

The consequences are visible upon almost every popular stretch of inland water.

Nowhere is this more apparent than in the apparently charitable, but frequently disastrous, behaviour of the modern powerboat owner when confronted with a sailing yacht or rowing boat.

 

An unfortunate act of consideration

The scene will be familiar to anyone who has spent a pleasant afternoon sailing or rowing upon a river.

A motorboat approaches at speed, comfortably established upon the plane, its hull skimming efficiently across the surface.

Its occupant notices a smaller, slower craft ahead.

Perhaps a sailing yacht, proceeding gracefully under canvas. Perhaps a rowing shell, whose occupants are engaged in the admirable pursuit of propelling themselves through water without the assistance of several hundred horsepower.

The powerboat driver, wishing to demonstrate consideration, reduces his speed.

An apparently commendable gesture.

Unfortunately, he reduces it by precisely the wrong amount.

Rather than slowing to a modest displacement speed, the vessel settles into that most objectionable condition somewhere between efficient planing and sensible progress through the water.

The bow rises. The stern digs in. The engine labours.

And behind the vessel develops a mountainous procession of water, sufficient to suggest that a minor geological event has occurred beneath the surface.

The unsuspecting oarsman, who had moments earlier been enjoying an entirely agreeable afternoon, finds himself confronted by a succession of waves of quite unnecessary proportions.

The sailing yacht heels indignantly, her sails flog, and the crew abandon whatever useful activity they had been undertaking in order to contend with the consequences of another man’s courtesy.

The motorboat driver, meanwhile, proceeds slowly onwards, secure in the knowledge that he has behaved with exemplary consideration.

He may even offer a friendly wave.

The Committee regards this final gesture as particularly offensive.

 

A brief excursion into linear wave theory

The explanation, of course, is not especially mysterious.

Linear wave theory provides a useful starting point for understanding the propagation of surface waves and the relationship between wavelength, frequency, water depth and wave speed.

A conventional planing powerboat, however, introduces further complications, not least the hydrodynamic resistance and displacement of water as the hull moves through the various regimes of operation.

At low displacement speeds, she may proceed with relatively little disturbance.

As power is increased, however, she approaches the limits of efficient displacement operation. The bow rises, the stern settles and the vessel begins expending a remarkable quantity of energy in the production of waves.

The resistance increases substantially as she approaches the transition to planing.

At last, with sufficient power, the hull climbs onto the plane. Less of her remains immersed, and the pattern of wash changes accordingly.

For many planing craft, the greatest waves are generated not at their normal cruising speed, but during that unhappy intermediate condition in which the vessel is attempting to climb over her own bow wave.

It is a principle which ought to be familiar to anyone entrusted with the command of such a boat.

The correct response when approaching smaller craft is therefore not to reduce speed by some arbitrary amount which merely feels considerate.

It is to understand the characteristics of one’s vessel and act accordingly.

Where conditions, regulations, separation and safety permit, a vessel already properly established upon the plane may produce considerably less wash than one wallowing along just below it.

Otherwise, the considerate skipper should slow decisively to a genuinely low-wash displacement speed, leaving ample room and observing the effect of his passage.

The essential point is not that speed is inherently virtuous.

It is that the quantity of disturbance caused by a vessel cannot always be judged by the apparent moderation of its speed.

The Committee accepts that this requires a modest appreciation of hydrodynamics.

It nevertheless considers such knowledge rather more useful than the ability to adjust the colour of one’s underwater lighting from a mobile telephone.

 

The difference between courtesy and competence

There is a broader lesson here.

The powerboat driver genuinely believes himself to be acting considerately.

His intentions may be entirely honourable.

Yet the consequences of his intervention are considerably worse than those which might have arisen had he understood his vessel and exercised proper judgement.

This is one of the great difficulties of the modern world.

Good intentions are increasingly treated as an adequate substitute for competence.

They are not.

A courteous incompetent remains incompetent, however agreeable his manner.

The Committee has encountered this phenomenon in numerous walks of life.

There are motorists who stop unexpectedly in the middle of the road to permit another vehicle to proceed, thereby creating confusion where previously there was none.

There are hotel architects who provide enormous jacuzzis in every bedroom while neglecting the apparently trivial business of supplying coffee before seven in the morning.

And there are powerboat owners who, in their eagerness to display consideration towards fellow water users, succeed in transferring a substantial proportion of the river into their wake.

The underlying error is identical.

The individual wishes to do the right thing without first acquiring the knowledge necessary to know what the right thing is.

The Committee considers this a most unsatisfactory arrangement.

 

Further consequences of nautical ignorance

It is, of course, difficult to contemplate the individual responsible for such an extraordinary display of wash generation without wondering what other calamities he might inflict upon the unsuspecting public.

One imagines him approaching a crowded marina with considerable confidence, entirely unaware that a vessel’s momentum does not disappear merely because its engine has been placed in neutral.

Having misjudged his approach, he applies a generous quantity of reverse thrust, directing an impressive torrent of water towards a neighbouring yacht whose owner had been enjoying a peaceful afternoon upon the stern.

The resulting disturbance is attributed to an unexpected gust of wind.

Later, the same skipper may find himself puzzled by the reluctance of his vessel to turn sharply at speed, having assumed that the laws of vehicle dynamics apply to boats in precisely the same manner as they do to his motor car.

The discovery that water offers rather less lateral resistance than a well-surfaced road is made at considerable expense.

There is also the matter of anchoring.

One can readily picture our enthusiastic motorist arriving in a crowded anchorage, selecting a position of apparently excellent convenience and deploying his anchor with little consideration for wind, tide, swinging circles or the unfortunate vessels already occupying the surrounding water.

He retires below, entirely satisfied with his arrangements.

Some hours later, the owners of three neighbouring yachts find themselves unexpectedly participating in a collective exercise in ground-tackle management.

The Committee would also be interested to observe his approach to mooring lines.

The widespread tendency to regard a line as adequately secured merely because it has been wound repeatedly around a cleat is one of the more depressing developments in modern seamanship.

Knots, it seems, have become another of those traditional skills which the contemporary consumer considers unnecessary.

Perhaps most alarming, however, is the prospect of such an individual encountering a navigation mark.

The established system of buoys, lights and shapes represents centuries of accumulated maritime experience, reduced to a language sufficiently straightforward to be understood by almost anyone prepared to learn it.

Yet one suspects that our unfortunate skipper would regard the red and green marks chiefly as decorative features of the waterway, their practical significance remaining a matter for speculation.

Indeed, the Committee finds it difficult to believe that such ignorance can be confined exclusively to the water.

One is inevitably led to wonder how the individual concerned conducts himself in other aspects of life.

Does he, for instance, possess the elementary judgement necessary to distinguish between a red and a white wine glass? Can he operate a dishwasher without first consulting an instructional video? Is he among those unfortunate motorists who believe that the rear fog lamp should be illuminated whenever the weather becomes vaguely disagreeable?

The possibilities are deeply troubling.

One imagines him arriving at a respectable restaurant and immediately requesting the Wi-Fi password, before enquiring whether the chef might accommodate a series of personal preferences wholly incompatible with the cuisine being served.

Perhaps he is the sort of person who applauds when an aeroplane lands, stands immediately upon reaching the terminal despite the seatbelt sign remaining illuminated, and then expresses astonishment that the baggage has not yet appeared upon the carousel.

At home, he may well be responsible for the sort of domestic calamities which the Committee prefers not to contemplate. A washing machine loaded with sufficient enthusiasm to require structural reinforcement. A thermostat adjusted repeatedly in the belief that setting it to thirty degrees will cause the house to warm more quickly. A perfectly serviceable bottle of Champagne subjected to the indignity of being opened with a corkscrew.

One shudders to imagine his approach to the preparation of a gin and tonic.

Does he understand the function of ice? Has he encountered the concept of a suitable measure? Might he, in an excess of misplaced innovation, consider cucumber an appropriate garnish without first establishing whether the gin in question warrants such treatment?

More serious still is the possibility that he may possess opinions.

Indeed, it seems entirely conceivable that an individual so thoroughly unacquainted with the elementary principles of wave generation might nevertheless feel himself qualified to pronounce upon matters of economics, engineering, foreign affairs and the proper administration of the country.

The Committee has observed that ignorance in one field does not invariably discourage confidence in another.

Quite the contrary.

There is a particular class of modern individual whose certainty appears to increase in direct proportion to his unfamiliarity with the subject under discussion.

The Committee naturally excludes its own members from this observation.

Their opinions, however forcefully expressed and occasionally contradictory, are founded upon a combination of experience, intellectual curiosity and the considerable wisdom accumulated through years of distinguished club membership.

The distinction is fundamental.

It is, of course, possible that the offending powerboat owner is in every other respect a competent, thoughtful and thoroughly agreeable person.

He may be an excellent cook, a devoted family man, a distinguished professional and an accomplished conversationalist.

The Committee readily acknowledges this possibility.

It simply considers the available evidence insufficient to justify so charitable a conclusion.

 

On the merits of exclusivity

It is at this point that the discussion inevitably turns to exclusivity.

The BSYC has never concealed its conviction that exclusivity is among the more beneficial features of a properly ordered society.

This position is frequently misunderstood.

We are assured, with increasing regularity, that every activity must become accessible, every institution welcoming and every privilege available to anyone who expresses an interest.

The Committee finds this curious.

Certain activities require knowledge, judgement and experience.

Flying an aeroplane, performing surgery, navigating a yacht and preparing a proper soufflé are not undertakings which benefit from the wholesale abandonment of established standards.

One would not ordinarily entrust the controls of an aircraft to an individual simply because he admired the colour of its upholstery.

Yet the modern leisure industry appears to consider that the purchase of an expensive motorboat is sufficient evidence of its owner’s capacity to operate it.

The Committee is not persuaded.

Exclusivity, properly understood, need not be concerned with social standing or the possession of a suitable blazer.

Though the Club naturally recognises the considerable merits of the latter.

Its more serious purpose is the preservation of standards.

There is value in institutions which expect their members to know something, to conduct themselves appropriately and to acquire the judgement necessary to participate in a particular activity.

A yacht club ought to be a place where seamanship is understood, traditions are respected and ignorance is corrected before it becomes a public nuisance.

Membership should represent rather more than the ability to pay a subscription.

The Committee has occasionally been accused of snobbery for expressing this view.

It considers the accusation substantially correct, though hardly persuasive.

 

The unfortunate distinction between owning and knowing

A recurring difficulty of the modern age is the confusion between ownership and mastery.

One may purchase the finest racing bicycle in existence without acquiring the ability to ride it competently.

One may own an extraordinary motor car without understanding the principles of vehicle dynamics.

And one may acquire a magnificent yacht without possessing the judgement necessary to bring her safely into harbour.

These are distinctions which ought to be obvious.

Yet modern commerce has devoted considerable energy to obscuring them.

The purchaser is encouraged to believe that the acquisition of sophisticated equipment constitutes an achievement in itself.

The actual acquisition of skill, experience and judgement is relegated to an optional extra.

The Committee regrets this development.

For the serious yachtsman, the pleasures of sailing are inseparable from the knowledge required to practise it well.

The understanding of wind and tide, the balancing of a hull, the setting of sails, the interpretation of weather and the quiet satisfaction of a manoeuvre properly executed are among the principal rewards of the sport.

It is precisely because these things demand effort that their mastery is worthwhile.

To remove the requirement for understanding is not necessarily to improve the experience.

It may simply diminish it.

The Committee is therefore inclined to the view that the democratisation of an activity, however agreeable in principle, is not invariably accompanied by an improvement in its standards.

There are occasions when a modest barrier to entry performs a useful service.

Particularly when the alternative is an individual in a fifty-thousand-pound motorboat attempting to tow half the river behind him.

 

The yacht club as the last refuge

Fortunately, there remain institutions in which such distinctions are still understood.

The properly constituted yacht club is among the finest of them.

Wherever a yachtsman may find himself, from the waters of the Mediterranean to the harbours of northern Europe, the sight of an established clubhouse remains a source of considerable reassurance.

Beyond its gates may lie the noise, vulgarity and general confusion of the modern leisure industry.

Within, one may reasonably expect to find a bar, a collection of well-maintained trophies, a few comfortable chairs and several yachtsmen willing to explain, at considerable length, precisely how everyone else is doing things incorrectly.

The Committee considers this one of the great advantages of the international yachting establishment.

The yacht club preserves a community founded not merely upon the ownership of boats, but upon a common appreciation of seamanship, tradition and the proper conduct of life afloat.

It is a refuge from the madding crowd.

A place where one may escape the apparent determination of the wider world to substitute enthusiasm for expertise, convenience for judgement and possession for accomplishment.

The conversation may occasionally become heated.

The opinions expressed may be contradictory.

And the company may contain individuals whose own seamanship would not necessarily survive the scrutiny they so enthusiastically apply to others.

These are regrettable but familiar characteristics of club life.

The Committee sees no reason to interfere with them.

Indeed, the BSYC has long maintained that its members possess an almost unlimited right to criticise the conduct of other yachtsmen, provided that their own shortcomings are discussed only in private and preferably after dinner.

 

A final observation

The Committee does not propose that motorboats should be abolished.

Such a measure would be unnecessarily severe, particularly as several members own perfectly agreeable examples themselves.

Nor does it suggest that every powerboat owner is ignorant of the principles governing his vessel.

There remain many excellent motor yachtsmen whose competence, courtesy and understanding of the sea command the Club’s wholehearted respect.

The objection is not to power.

It is to ignorance.

And more particularly, to ignorance masquerading as consideration.

A properly handled motorboat is a fine thing. A poorly handled one is an expensive means of inconveniencing everyone within several hundred yards.

The Committee therefore urges those unfamiliar with the principles of hull resistance, wave formation and planing to acquire a little knowledge before next taking to the water.

They may find that their vessels behave rather better than expected.

Their neighbours will certainly appreciate the improvement.

And should they remain uncertain as to the appropriate course of action, they are encouraged to consult an experienced yachtsman.

Such individuals are generally easy to identify.

They are frequently to be found in yacht clubs, wearing blazers, expressing strong opinions and explaining why things were better in the past.

The Committee acknowledges that these characteristics do not provide an infallible guarantee of competence.

They are, however, an excellent starting point.

For while almost anybody may acquire a boat, it remains the particular distinction of a yachtsman to know what to do with one.

And if the Club may be permitted one final observation:

It is an immutable fact that yachtsmen generally do things properly. Where they do not, they are at least sufficiently well acquainted with the rules to know which ones they are breaking.

By order of the Committee

The Amsterdam Expedition

The Amsterdam Expedition


A Yacht Was Inspected

An account of a maritime expedition to the Netherlands, the wisdom of Erasmus, a remarkable quantity of Dutch engineering, and the relative merits of butter, olive oil and civilised seamanship.

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club has long maintained that the acquisition of a yacht is a matter demanding considerable deliberation.

A gentleman ought not to purchase a vessel merely because she is attractive, conveniently located or offered at a favourable price. Such considerations belong to ordinary commercial transactions and have little place in the serious business of yacht ownership.

A suitable yacht must possess character, pedigree and that indefinable quality which distinguishes a proper racing vessel from a floating exercise in modern domestic convenience.

It was therefore entirely appropriate that a prospective addition to the Club’s fleet should occasion an international expedition involving members travelling independently from North Wales and the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg.

The destination was Harlingen, a small Dutch port upon the Wadden Sea.

The objective was the inspection of a Farr-designed Mumm 36, built by Cookson in 1993, whose considerable sporting pedigree had naturally attracted the attention of the Club.

Her name, at the time, was something altogether less distinguished.

The Committee sees little purpose in reproducing it here.

Suffice it to say that corporate sponsorship has inflicted many indignities upon the world of competitive yachting, and that a proper racing yacht ought not to resemble an advertisement for a commercial undertaking.

This particular deficiency would eventually be corrected.

 

An expedition of considerable promise

The arrangements were undertaken with the customary combination of enthusiasm and logistical extravagance which characterises the Club’s continental activities.

One member departed North Wales by aeroplane, while another undertook the considerable journey northwards from Luxembourg by motor car.

The latter journey, by means of a route through portions of the Dutch Bible Belt, provided an unexpected opportunity to observe that curious stretch of the Netherlands where traditional religious observance and conservative social habits persist with a determination increasingly uncommon elsewhere in Europe.

The Committee viewed this discovery with considerable satisfaction.

Here, evidently, remained a population which had not yet succumbed entirely to the fashionable conviction that every established custom must be discarded simply because it has survived for several centuries.

Whether such an environment might exert a beneficial influence upon the fortunes of a prospective racing yacht was a matter of some speculation.

The Almighty has, insofar as the Committee is aware, expressed no particular preference for the International Offshore Rule or its successors.

Nevertheless, the proximity of so much religious observance was generally regarded as a favourable omen.

A yacht acquired after travelling through the Bible Belt might reasonably be expected to enjoy a degree of providential protection, although the Committee understands that divine intervention is not presently recognised as a valid ground for redress under the Racing Rules of Sailing.

Harlingen itself proved most agreeable.

The Dutch have long possessed an understanding of boats which deserves the admiration of every serious yachtsman. A maritime people by necessity as much as inclination, they have spent centuries building vessels, navigating shallow waters and defending their precarious existence against the sea.

Their harbours retain a character increasingly absent elsewhere: proper working quays, handsome traditional buildings and an unmistakable sense that boats remain part of the national identity rather than merely expensive recreational accessories.

It was in these surroundings that the prospective acquisition awaited inspection.

Or, more precisely, in a shed.

 

A most satisfactory yacht

The yacht herself was found to be in immaculate condition.

This was a considerable relief.

The Committee has become accustomed to encountering vessels described by their owners as being in excellent order, only to discover that the expression means little more than that the hull remains approximately watertight.

Such was not the case here.

A Farr-designed Mumm 36 is a serious racing machine. She belongs to that distinguished generation of yachts conceived primarily to win races rather than accommodate the domestic ambitions of their owners.

She possesses the lean, purposeful lines of a proper offshore racer, with little evidence of the unfortunate tendency to confuse yacht design with the construction of floating holiday apartments.

The Committee approved.

Her surroundings, however, were less reassuring.

The yacht was housed in an exceptionally dusty shed, supported upon a cradle whose structural integrity invited a degree of speculation which the assembled company considered best not pursued too enthusiastically.

There are few sights more disconcerting than a distinguished racing yacht resting several feet above a concrete floor upon an arrangement of timber and steel which appears to owe more to optimism than engineering.

The cradle had evidently performed its duties satisfactorily thus far.

Whether this constituted evidence of sound design or merely extraordinary good fortune remained unclear.

The inspection proceeded with appropriate caution, and the yacht herself emerged with considerable credit.

A prospective addition to the Club’s fleet had been found.

The expedition had fulfilled its stated purpose.

There remained, however, a substantial portion of the Netherlands to traverse and an evening in Amsterdam to negotiate.

 

Of dams, Dutchmen and the inconvenience of the sea

The return journey towards Amsterdam took the company across the Afsluitdijk, that extraordinary Dutch engineering achievement which separates the Wadden Sea from the great freshwater expanse of the IJsselmeer.

Stretching some thirty-two kilometres across what was once the open Zuiderzee, the structure represents one of the more magnificent examples of mankind’s refusal to accept its geographical circumstances.

Confronted with the inconvenience of living in a country perpetually threatened by the sea, the Dutch did not merely complain, establish a committee or commission an expensive study.

They built a dam.

An enormous one.

And, having successfully excluded the sea, proceeded to reclaim substantial portions of the land behind it.

The Committee considers this a thoroughly admirable approach to problem-solving.

There is something wonderfully reassuring about a civilisation which, when presented with a geographical difficulty, responds by altering the geography.

The drive prompted spirited conversation concerning land reclamation, the management of rivers and estuaries, and the Dutch conviction that an entirely satisfactory expanse of sea might be improved by turning it into farmland.

The implications for sailing were naturally examined.

Freshwater yachting has much to recommend it. Fittings are spared the ravages of salt, maintenance becomes a more agreeable occupation, and yachts may be preserved in a condition of cleanliness which coastal sailors can only envy.

There are, however, philosophical questions.

Can a gentleman truly claim to have gone to sea when the water beneath his keel is fresh?

Does the transformation of a saltwater inlet into an inland lake diminish its maritime standing?

And at what point does a successful civil engineering project become a threat to the interests of yachtsmen?

The Dutch achievement was nevertheless impossible to deny.

Here was a nation which had spent centuries shaping its environment through ingenuity, discipline and enormous collective effort.

It was a magnificent demonstration of what can be achieved when a people possess sufficient confidence to undertake something difficult.

The conversation might have continued indefinitely, had Amsterdam not eventually intervened.

 

A most satisfactory dinner

Having completed the inspection and returned to Amsterdam, the company proceeded directly to dinner.

There was no time to be squandered upon hotel formalities. The business of checking into accommodation could wait; the restoration of proper standards after a day of continental motoring could not.

A restaurant of suitable distinction had been selected in central Amsterdam.

The establishment was Italian, the surroundings excellent and the service of a standard which immediately restored the company’s confidence in the hospitality industry.

Gin was taken.

A particularly fine Gavi was selected, at a price which occasioned a moment’s reflection but no serious objection.

The Committee has always maintained that economy, while commendable in the management of public finances, is an unattractive consideration when choosing wine.

The Gavi was quite exceptional.

It was at this point that the first serious disagreement of the evening arose.

Bread had arrived at the table.

With olive oil.

No butter was offered.

For a party containing gentlemen of northern European disposition, this represented a notable departure from established custom.

Bread, it was observed, has been served with butter across much of the civilised world for generations, and the arrangement has proved perfectly satisfactory.

There seemed little obvious reason to abandon it.

The Italian position, however, was not without merit.

A good olive oil possesses an elegance and freshness particularly suited to Mediterranean cooking. It requires little preparation, complements excellent bread and avoids the unnecessary complication of refrigeration.

More importantly, it cannot be served too cold.

This last consideration attracted considerable support.

Few culinary experiences are more dispiriting than receiving a handsome piece of bread accompanied by a small, impenetrable block of butter apparently maintained at a temperature more appropriate to the preservation of Antarctic ice cores.

A gentleman is then obliged to attack his bread with a knife, frequently destroying its structure in the attempt to distribute a substance which refuses to yield.

It is an entirely unnecessary indignity.

Olive oil, by contrast, presents itself ready for immediate service.

No waiting, no scraping, no fractured bread.

The Committee was forced to acknowledge that the Mediterranean arrangement possessed certain advantages.

This concession, however, prompted a wider debate.

 

Of butter, olive oil and the dangers of progress

The question was no longer merely culinary.

It concerned the circumstances in which established tradition ought properly to yield to innovation.

Butter is an institution. Its merits have been demonstrated over centuries, and its place upon the northern European luncheon table is beyond serious dispute.

Yet there is little virtue in defending an excellent tradition when its execution has become manifestly unsatisfactory.

A frozen pat of butter, served in the name of custom, is no more agreeable than an inferior olive oil presented in the name of modern sophistication.

The distinction, it was argued, lies not between old and new, but between good and bad.

This is a principle which the modern world appears increasingly determined to overlook.

Yachting provides numerous examples.

The Committee has long lamented the disappearance of proper seamanship beneath a bewildering accumulation of electronic conveniences. Yet only the most unreasonable traditionalist would deny the considerable merits of a reliable chartplotter, modern sailcloth or an efficient self-tailing winch.

Such improvements have made the business of sailing demonstrably better.

The difficulty arises when innovation ceases to serve a purpose and becomes an end in itself.

A yacht does not become more seaworthy merely because its instruments communicate with a telephone. Nor does an electronic display confer upon its owner the judgement which generations of sailors acquired through experience.

The modern world, alas, has developed a peculiar habit of improving things which function perfectly well while neglecting those which plainly do not.

The Committee therefore arrived at a provisional doctrine.

Tradition should be preserved wherever it serves its purpose. Innovation should be welcomed wherever it genuinely improves upon it. Everything else is merely interference.

The difficulty, naturally, lies in deciding who is qualified to make such judgements.

The assembled company considered itself eminently suitable.

The waiter, meanwhile, continued serving olive oil.

The argument had scarcely been resolved when the main courses arrived.

One member had selected a magnificent veal chop, of proportions which suggested that the animal concerned had enjoyed a reasonably substantial existence.

Another ordered a beautifully prepared piece of fish, accompanied by gremolata, whose freshness and sharpness provided a compelling demonstration of the virtues of Mediterranean cooking.

The Gavi proved an admirable companion to both.

Further gin was consumed, and the conversation moved on to less contentious matters, including yacht racing, the shortcomings of modern travel and the curious behaviour of European institutions.

It was precisely the sort of evening which justifies undertaking an otherwise unnecessary journey across several international borders.

 

An evening in Amsterdam

Following dinner, the company embarked upon an evening stroll through central Amsterdam.

The city possesses an atmosphere quite unlike anywhere else in Europe. Its canals, narrow streets and handsome merchant houses speak of centuries of trade, wealth, seafaring and the extraordinary confidence of the Dutch Golden Age.

Here was a city built upon the conviction that commerce, navigation, architecture and civilisation might flourish together.

For a Club devoted to the traditions of yachting, these were admirable foundations.

Passing through Dam Square, however, the conversation assumed a more reflective character.

The National Monument stands as a reminder of the Netherlands’ suffering during the Second World War, and of the terrible price paid under Nazi occupation.

Amsterdam’s wartime history is particularly painful. The persecution and deportation of its Jewish population, the suffering of civilians and the destruction wrought by occupation remain among the darkest chapters in European history.

There was little cause for levity.

The company reflected upon the generation which had endured those years and upon the freedoms and institutions which had survived them.

The Netherlands had emerged from occupation, rebuilt itself and continued its remarkable national story.

It was a sobering reminder that the peace and prosperity enjoyed by modern Europeans were neither inevitable nor cheaply acquired.

The subsequent Uber journey towards the docklands afforded an opportunity to continue the discussion.

Some concern was expressed that modern Western society appeared increasingly uncomfortable with its own inheritance, inclined to dwell upon historical failings while overlooking the extraordinary achievements of the generations which preceded it.

This was not to deny those failings, nor the importance of remembering them.

Rather, it was suggested that a mature civilisation ought to possess sufficient confidence to acknowledge both its virtues and its mistakes without treating the entirety of its past as a source of embarrassment.

The Dutch, after all, had built magnificent cities, established great maritime traditions and reclaimed an inland sea.

There seemed much worth preserving.

The driver, to his considerable credit, offered no opinion.

The Committee regards his restraint as admirable.

 

The question of accommodation

It was only after dinner, the evening stroll and the return journey through Amsterdam that the company finally arrived at its hotel in the docklands.

The establishment was of that peculiar modern corporate variety which endeavours to distinguish itself through expensive design flourishes while neglecting several of the more elementary obligations of hospitality.

Its most extraordinary feature was the provision of a vast jacuzzi bath, positioned prominently within each guest room.

The Committee has no particular objection to bathing.

Indeed, when conducted privately, efficiently and without excessive ceremony, it remains one of the more commendable habits of civilised society.

But the spectacle of an enormous jacuzzi occupying pride of place in what was otherwise an entirely ordinary hotel room raised several questions.

The first concerned taste.

The second concerned structural engineering.

It was observed that, were every guest in the establishment to fill his bath simultaneously, the resulting weight of water, machinery and occupants might represent a considerable additional burden upon the building.

Had the architect allowed for this eventuality?

Were the floors reinforced?

Had anyone calculated the consequences of several storeys of enthusiastic bathers simultaneously availing themselves of the facilities?

The matter was debated with considerable seriousness.

Attention then turned to the plumbing.

Even if the building could withstand the combined weight of its bathing guests, could the hot-water system possibly satisfy such extraordinary demand?

There seemed little merit in constructing a hotel capable of accommodating a fleet of private jacuzzis if the first few occupants exhausted the hot-water supply for everybody else.

The Committee considered that a more sensible allocation of resources might have produced slightly smaller baths and considerably better service elsewhere.

This observation would prove prophetic.

 

The seven o’clock outrage

The following morning brought the expedition’s most serious disappointment.

Having risen at an hour appropriate to gentlemen obliged to undertake international travel, members sought the elementary comfort of a cup of coffee.

None was available.

The hotel had apparently determined that coffee should not be served before seven o’clock.

The company received this information with disbelief.

There are many privations which the travelling yachtsman must be prepared to endure. Unfavourable weather, delayed transport, questionable accommodation and the occasional indifferent harbour restaurant are familiar hazards.

But a modern hotel, equipped with vast private jacuzzis and presumably the engineering infrastructure necessary to support them, ought surely to possess the means of producing a cup of coffee before seven in the morning.

The contrast was extraordinary.

The establishment had evidently devoted considerable resources to the provision of elaborate bathing facilities whose simultaneous use might conceivably threaten the municipal water supply.

Yet the elementary business of boiling water and passing it through ground coffee had been deemed beyond its operational capabilities.

The Committee could not help observing that the Dutch had successfully excluded the North Sea, reclaimed vast tracts of land and constructed some of the most sophisticated hydraulic works in Europe.

The hotel could not provide coffee at six-thirty.

Here, in miniature, was the modern world.

Extraordinary technological achievement accompanied by the gradual abandonment of the most elementary standards of service.

One might reasonably ask whether the architect, having provided for the unlikely possibility of every guest simultaneously occupying a jacuzzi, had considered the rather more probable eventuality of several guests wishing to drink coffee before breakfast.

Apparently not.

The Committee does not propose to suggest that the decline of Western civilisation may be measured exclusively by the availability of early-morning coffee.

It does, however, consider the evidence increasingly compelling.

With this final disappointment duly recorded, the members took their leave of the Netherlands, dispersing once more towards North Wales and Luxembourg.

The journey was complete.

The business of the yacht, however, was not quite finished.

 

Erasmus, and the delicate matter of renaming

Following the expedition, and with the acquisition duly completed, there remained one final matter of considerable importance.

The yacht required a name.

Or, more precisely, a better one.

The Committee has never been particularly enthusiastic about the modern practice of naming racing yachts after commercial sponsors.

There was once a time when yachts bore names of elegance, character and occasionally considerable personal significance.

Today, a distinguished racing vessel may find herself obliged to carry the name of an insurance company, a software provider or some other commercial enterprise whose association with the sea is limited principally to the hospitality budget of its marketing department.

The previous name of the newly acquired Mumm 36 belonged to this regrettable tradition.

It shall not be reproduced in the annals of the BSYC.

The Committee considers that the yacht has suffered enough.

Renaming a vessel is, of course, a matter not undertaken lightly.

The old superstition that changing a yacht’s name invites the displeasure of Neptune is well established, and the Committee has no intention of dismissing centuries of maritime tradition merely because the scientific evidence is inconclusive.

Nevertheless, there are circumstances in which the interests of dignity must prevail.

It was therefore resolved that the yacht should henceforth be known as Erasmus.

The choice was particularly appropriate.

Desiderius Erasmus of Rotterdam was one of the great scholars of the Renaissance: a Dutch humanist, indefatigable traveller and perceptive observer of the absurdities of human society.

His friendships extended into England, most notably to Sir Thomas More, and his celebrated Praise of Folly remains a splendid reminder that mankind’s capacity for foolishness long predates the invention of the smartphone.

The Committee finds much to admire in Erasmus.

A learned man, an enthusiastic traveller and a critic of intellectual pretension, he might have made a most agreeable dinner companion.

Indeed, had he accompanied the expedition, one suspects he would have found ample material for a further volume.

The theological reflections of the Dutch Bible Belt, the engineering of the IJsselmeer, the culinary controversy surrounding bread and olive oil, and the extraordinary jacuzzi arrangements of an Amsterdam hotel would surely have appealed to his sense of human folly.

Whether he would have approved of the yacht herself is less certain.

But a proper racing vessel bearing the name of a distinguished Renaissance scholar seemed an altogether more satisfactory arrangement than one advertising the commercial ambitions of an unrelated enterprise.

As for Neptune, the Committee trusts that the god of the sea, having been acquainted with the circumstances, will recognise the necessity of the change.

Even ancient deities must surely possess some appreciation for good taste.

 

A worthy addition to the fleet

Thus concluded a most satisfactory expedition, whose eventual outcome was the arrival of a distinguished new yacht in the BSYC fleet.

A vessel had been inspected and found in excellent condition, notwithstanding the questionable cradle upon which she had rested.

The engineering achievements of the Netherlands had been admired, the philosophical implications of freshwater sailing debated and the country’s extraordinary maritime heritage given its proper recognition.

A magnificent dinner had been enjoyed, accompanied by considerable quantities of gin, a distinguished Gavi, an exceptional veal chop and a spirited debate concerning the merits of olive oil and butter.

The history of occupied Amsterdam had occasioned proper reflection.

The structural implications of excessive bathing had been considered.

And the hospitality industry’s failure to provide coffee before seven o’clock had been duly condemned.

All in all, it had been a most productive undertaking.

It is perhaps a peculiar characteristic of the BSYC that a straightforward excursion to inspect a racing yacht should develop into a comprehensive examination of Dutch geography, Renaissance philosophy, European history, culinary tradition and the structural loading of hotel bathrooms.

But the Committee has never considered a journey successful merely because its original purpose was achieved.

Travel should broaden the mind, confirm one’s prejudices where appropriate, and occasionally provide sufficient evidence to justify acquiring new ones.

The Netherlands had proved a country of extraordinary accomplishment, admirable nautical heritage and much remaining charm.

And the BSYC fleet had acquired a most worthy addition.

Erasmus, a Cookson-built Mumm 36, would henceforth represent the Club upon the racing waters of North Wales, where her new company might reasonably be expected to uphold the finest traditions of competitive yachting.

The Committee considers the expedition an unqualified success.

It remains, however, profoundly disappointed about the coffee.

The Burgee Affair

The Burgee Affair


An Outrage Against Sovereignty

Concerning the unlawful appropriation of Club colours, a regrettable incident in the South West of England, and the apparent failure of international maritime law to protect the rights of gentlemen.

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club has always maintained that membership is a privilege, not an entitlement.

It is a distinction which the modern world, in its tiresome enthusiasm for equality, accessibility and the wholesale dismantling of established standards, appears increasingly incapable of understanding.

The Club is not a public institution. It does not solicit applications, advertise its attractions or concern itself unduly with the aspirations of those unfortunate enough to find themselves excluded from its company.

Indeed, the Committee has long considered that the principal virtue of a private club lies not in the people who belong to it, but in the vastly greater number who do not.

It was therefore with a mixture of astonishment and profound displeasure that reports recently reached the Committee of an unidentified vessel in the South West of England displaying what appeared unmistakably to be the burgee of the BSYC.

The vessel was not known to the Club.

Its owner was not a member.

And, most damningly of all, the burgee was being flown incorrectly.

An outrage against the sovereignty of the Club had occurred.

 

A most unfortunate discovery

The precise circumstances of the discovery need not concern us here. It is sufficient to record that a vessel having no legitimate association with the BSYC was observed displaying the Club’s distinctive colours in a manner wholly inconsistent with established yachting practice.

Initially, an innocent explanation was considered. Perhaps a member had acquired a new yacht without informing the Committee. Perhaps the vessel had been borrowed, or the colours temporarily entrusted to a fellow yachtsman for some entirely respectable purpose.

Such explanations, though unlikely, were not beyond contemplation.

However, closer examination revealed a far more disturbing fact.

The burgee was not flying from the masthead.

The significance of this observation cannot be overstated.

Under the Club’s regulations, the BSYC burgee is to be flown from the masthead upon a suitable pigstick, or, in the case of a motor vessel, from an appropriately dignified mast provided for that purpose.

This is not a recommendation. It is not an invitation to personal interpretation.

It is a fundamental principle of the established nautical order.

The display of a Club burgee from a spreader, backstay, guardrail or other improvised appendage is not an expression of individuality. It is a public confession of ignorance.

A gentleman may occasionally be forgiven an error of navigation, a poorly executed tack or even an unfortunate choice of luncheon companion.

He cannot be forgiven for not knowing where to fly his burgee.

 

The unmistakable mark of an impostor

The Committee has given considerable thought to the motives of the offender.

It is possible that the individual simply admired the Club’s colours and, in a moment of misplaced enthusiasm, decided to acquire them.

This would be understandable.

The BSYC has, despite its best efforts to discourage unnecessary attention, acquired a reputation for distinction which naturally attracts the admiration of those outside its ranks.

Throughout history, men of modest standing have sought to improve their social circumstances through association with their betters.

Such ambitions are not, in themselves, objectionable.

Their fulfilment is quite another matter.

The possession of a Club burgee does not confer membership, any more than the purchase of a crown entitles its wearer to occupy the throne.

More importantly, the offender’s ignorance of burgee etiquette provides conclusive evidence of imposture.

No properly admitted member of the BSYC could conceivably be unaware of the correct manner in which the Club’s colours are to be displayed.

It follows, therefore, that an individual flying them incorrectly cannot be a member.

The reasoning is, in the Committee’s view, unassailable.

Indeed, it renders any consultation of the membership register largely unnecessary.

One may counterfeit a burgee. One cannot counterfeit a gentleman.

 

The decline of flag etiquette

It is a regrettable feature of modern yachting that the proper use of flags has increasingly become a matter of indifference.

One encounters ensigns of improbable dimensions, courtesy flags hoisted in entirely inappropriate positions, and decorative pennants whose origins and significance appear unknown even to those displaying them.

The modern yachtsman, having purchased a vessel equipped with electronic navigation, hydraulic conveniences and an extraordinary number of cupholders, frequently imagines that he has thereby acquired the entirety of the knowledge necessary to command her.

He has not.

There was a time when a gentleman entering harbour understood instinctively which colours were to be flown, where they belonged and what obligations accompanied them.

The ensign proclaimed nationality. The courtesy flag acknowledged the waters of a foreign sovereign. The burgee identified a yacht’s club affiliation and, by extension, the standing of those aboard her.

These were not matters of decoration.

They were the visible language of a maritime civilisation, understood by yachtsmen whose education extended somewhat beyond the operation of a touchscreen.

Today, alas, flags are increasingly treated as accessories, selected according to colour, convenience or their compatibility with the upholstery.

A yacht-club burgee is not bunting.

Nor is it a souvenir of an agreeable afternoon spent drinking at the bar of an establishment to which one does not belong.

It is a mark of membership, and membership is the consequence of admission, not acquisition.

That so elementary a distinction should require explanation is itself a damning indictment of the age.

 

An affront to sovereignty

The implications of the affair extend far beyond the improper display of a piece of cloth.

If an individual may simply appropriate the colours of a distinguished yacht club, what then becomes of the institution’s sovereignty?

What purpose is served by membership rules, committees, elections, traditions and the considerable effort expended upon excluding unsuitable candidates?

The Committee considers the matter comparable, in principle, to the unlawful assumption of an ambassadorial flag, the wearing of decorations to which one is not entitled, or the occupation of a reserved table at a respectable luncheon establishment.

These are not trivial offences.

They strike at the foundations of an ordered society.

It is therefore astonishing that international maritime law appears to offer so little explicit protection to the sovereignty of yacht-club burgees.

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, despite its considerable length and evident ambition, appears to have devoted an entirely inadequate proportion of its attention to the matter.

The Committee can only presume that this omission arose through oversight.

It has been suggested that the matter might be referred to the European Union, although the Committee has little appetite for discovering how many regulations, working groups and mandatory consultations would be required before Brussels could agree upon which end of a pigstick was uppermost.

The Club has therefore resolved, at least for the present, to defend its own colours.

 

Progress, whether required or not

The incident is symptomatic of a wider and altogether more depressing phenomenon.

We live in an age possessed by the curious conviction that everything must be improved, particularly those things which have functioned perfectly satisfactorily for several centuries.

Traditions must be modernised. Institutions must become accessible. Established practices must be reviewed, reconsidered and ultimately replaced by arrangements which are invariably more complicated and seldom better.

The question of whether improvement is actually required rarely seems to arise.

The maritime world has suffered particularly from this affliction.

Yachts have become floating apartment buildings. Navigation has been entrusted to screens. Seamanship is increasingly mistaken for proficiency in operating electronic equipment, and the once respectable yacht club is gradually being transformed into a species of leisure centre.

Even the simple business of flying a flag, governed for generations by established custom, is now apparently considered an opportunity for personal expression.

The Committee regards this with profound disappointment.

There is nothing inherently virtuous about novelty.

A practice does not become obsolete merely because it is old, nor does an institution become better simply because it has abandoned the standards upon which it was founded.

Indeed, the Committee is increasingly persuaded that the principal achievement of modern progress has been to render straightforward matters unnecessarily complicated, while making genuinely important matters appear optional.

It was once sufficient for a gentleman to know his club, know his colours and know where to fly them.

Today, apparently, even this is asking too much.

 

On the appropriate consequences

The question of sanctions has naturally occupied much of the Committee’s attention.

A simple request that the offending burgee be removed was considered manifestly inadequate.

Several more appropriate measures were contemplated.

These included the immediate suspension of reciprocal hospitality privileges, whether or not such privileges had ever been granted; notification of the offender’s commodore, should he belong to an institution sufficiently respectable to possess one; and a demand for a formal written apology upon suitably heavy stationery.

One member proposed that the offending burgee be surrendered and ceremonially destroyed.

Another suggested that the vessel concerned be prohibited from approaching any yacht flying the legitimate colours of the BSYC.

A particularly vigorous contribution called for the establishment of an International Court of Yacht Club Heraldry, with jurisdiction over all cases of unauthorised burgee display.

This proposal attracted considerable enthusiasm, especially when it was suggested that the Court might be established in The Hague, thereby lending the proceedings an appropriate degree of continental solemnity.

The Committee has not ruled out the possibility.

It is, however, understood that the establishment of an international tribunal may require a budget, permanent staff and the occasional journey to the Netherlands.

There are limits to what even the BSYC is prepared to endure in defence of civilisation.

 

The Inspector-General of Club Colours

In the meantime, the Committee has resolved to consider the appointment of an Inspector-General of Club Colours.

The office would be responsible for identifying unauthorised displays of the BSYC burgee, investigating suspected cases of impersonation and recommending suitable disciplinary or diplomatic measures.

It has been pointed out that this proposal bears an unfortunate resemblance to the sort of unnecessary bureaucracy which the Club has traditionally condemned.

The comparison is entirely without merit.

Whereas modern bureaucracies exist principally to interfere with the lawful enjoyment of life, the Inspector-General would exist to preserve the established privileges of those properly entitled to enjoy it.

The distinction should be obvious to any reasonable person.

It is anticipated that the office would carry considerable prestige, entail very few actual duties and provide an entirely satisfactory justification for the appointment of another flag officer.

The Committee regards this as a most efficient arrangement.

 

The preservation of distinction

There is, of course, a certain satisfaction to be derived from the affair.

That an individual should wish to associate himself with the BSYC, despite possessing neither the invitation nor the qualifications necessary to do so, is perhaps the most sincere compliment the Club could receive.

Imitation has always been a consequence of distinction.

The established institutions of British society have long endured the attentions of pretenders, social climbers and others who imagine that the outward appearance of belonging might serve as a substitute for the genuine article.

The BSYC can hardly expect to escape the same fate.

Nevertheless, there is a difference between admiration and appropriation.

The modern world has become distressingly reluctant to acknowledge this distinction.

We are repeatedly informed that everything should be accessible, that every institution must broaden its appeal and that the preservation of exclusive privileges is somehow incompatible with the requirements of a progressive society.

The Committee takes a different view.

Not every door must be opened.

Not every tradition must be explained.

And not every burgee may be flown by anyone who happens to fancy its colours.

There is considerable merit in preserving institutions which make demands upon their members, maintain their own standards and decline to apologise for their existence.

Indeed, the Committee has long held that the principal problem with the modern world is not that it contains too many exclusive institutions, but that it contains far too few.

The BSYC intends to remain among them.

 

A final pronouncement

The Committee therefore reminds all yachtsmen that the BSYC burgee is a mark of membership, not an ornament to be purchased, borrowed or casually appropriated.

Its proper place is at the masthead, upon a suitable pigstick, or upon an appropriate mast in the case of a motor vessel.

Its display elsewhere shall be regarded as evidence of nautical ignorance, and where displayed by a vessel not affiliated with the Club, as an act of imposture.

Members are encouraged to remain vigilant and to report suspected infringements to the appropriate flag officer, preferably before luncheon.

The offending vessel in the South West of England is strongly advised to remove the unauthorised colours and reflect upon the seriousness of its conduct.

The Club does not ordinarily seek confrontation.

Nor does it particularly welcome correspondence from persons with whom it has no wish to associate.

Nevertheless, where the sovereignty of its colours is concerned, the Committee is prepared to make an exception.

For while a gentleman may sail beneath many flags, he may only fly the burgee of a club to which he belongs.

And if he does not know where to fly it, he would probably not have been invited to join in the first place.

A Dragon in the Swiss Alps

A Dragon in the Swiss Alps


There are few things in the modern world which have been improved by the passage of time. The International Dragon is one of the pleasing exceptions, having had the good sense to remain substantially as she was intended.

Conceived in 1929 by the Norwegian Johan Anker, at a time when gentlemen still dressed for dinner and yacht designers concerned themselves with matters of beauty rather than the accommodation of floating caravans, the Dragon remains among the most elegant racing yachts ever drawn.

Her long overhangs, low freeboard and impossibly graceful sheerline belong to an altogether more civilised age. She has no galley, no heads, no accommodation worthy of the name, and certainly nowhere to install a television. She exists for the singular purpose of sailing beautifully, and is all the better for it.

The great Uffa Fox, who knew a thing or two about making boats go quickly, famously declared that the only place for weight was in a steamroller. His enthusiasm for lively boats, sound design and the sheer pleasure of sailing made him one of the most entertaining authorities ever to put pen to paper. That he also raced Dragons in the company of His Royal Highness the Duke of Edinburgh is a further commendation, although the class scarcely requires one.

The Dragon asks much of her crew and offers very little in return beyond the satisfaction of having sailed her properly. It is an arrangement the Committee of the BSYC considers entirely reasonable.

One such example is Mustique, a yacht of considerable charm, distinguished affiliations and occasionally questionable geographical judgment.

An Englishman abroad

Mustique is campaigned by an Englishman resident in the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, a small but prosperous country which, despite possessing many of the essential prerequisites of civilisation, remains regrettably deficient in suitable expanses of water.

Accordingly, her owner has sought his sailing elsewhere, as Englishmen of a certain disposition have been doing for centuries.

Switzerland presents itself as the natural solution.

The English, after all, practically invented the business of visiting Switzerland for pleasure. It was the Victorian gentleman, armed with a Baedeker, a stout pair of boots and an unshakeable conviction in the superiority of British habits, who helped transform the Alpine wilderness into the playground of Europe’s fashionable classes.

They came to admire the mountains, conquer the peaks, drink tea upon hotel terraces and introduce such civilising institutions as lawn tennis, afternoon service and properly organised winter sports.

The Swiss, displaying their customary commercial good sense, supplied the railways, grand hotels, mountain guides and reassuringly substantial bills.

It was an arrangement of mutual benefit, and one which has continued remarkably successfully ever since.

Mustique now perpetuates this noble tradition of English Alpine tourism, although she has sensibly dispensed with the mountaineering and confined herself, for the most part, to the lake.

Her summer home is the Thunersee Yacht Club, on the shores of Lake Thun in the Bernese Oberland.

Here, beneath the magnificent prospect of the Eiger, Mönch and Jungfrau, the great Alpine peaks rise above a lake of extraordinary beauty. Elegant steamers ply the waters, villages cling to the wooded shores, and the distant mountains retain that air of permanence which the modern world has otherwise done so much to undermine.

On a fine summer afternoon, with the breeze descending from the mountains and a Dragon slipping gracefully across the lake, one might almost expect to find an Edwardian traveller observing proceedings from the terrace of a grand hotel, his afternoon tea interrupted only by the arrival of a telegram from London.

There are, it must be conceded, worse places in which to keep a yacht.

The Swiss conduct the business of sailing with much the same diligence they apply to banking, watchmaking and the discreet management of other people’s fortunes. The boats are immaculate, the clubs established, the racing keenly contested and the cost of participation sufficiently discouraging to maintain an appropriate standard of company.

Indeed, the Committee has long regarded Switzerland as reassuring evidence that the absence of a coastline need not preclude a thoroughly civilised yachting establishment.

The regrettable annual occurrence of winter

Alas, even the Swiss have yet to overcome the regrettable annual occurrence of winter.

This is not to suggest that winter is without its merits. Quite the contrary. The Committee has always considered skiing one of the few entirely respectable arguments in favour of the continued existence of snow.

There is much to commend in a properly conducted Alpine winter. The mountain air, the exhilarating descent of a well-groomed piste, the agreeable fatigue of an afternoon upon the slopes and, most importantly, the institution of lunch at altitude.

Indeed, the British contribution to the development of Alpine winter sports should be remembered with rather more gratitude than is generally forthcoming.

But what is splendid for the skier is decidedly less agreeable for the yachtsman.

Lake Thun, for all its extraordinary summer beauty, becomes a less hospitable environment for an open racing yacht as the season draws to its conclusion. The Eiger, Mönch and Jungfrau acquire their winter coats, the lakeside terraces surrender to the cold, and the prospect of spending several hours sitting upon the weather rail begins to lose some of its charm.

Mustique is therefore obliged, with considerable reluctance, to decamp to Cannes for the long winter months.

The Côte d’Azur is, of course, a place of mixed reputation.

Once the preserve of Europe’s aristocracy, statesmen and discreetly wealthy, the Riviera has in recent decades become increasingly associated with enormous motor yachts, conspicuous displays of questionable taste and people who consider a bottle of Champagne improved by the addition of a sparkler.

Nevertheless, Cannes possesses two considerable advantages: a Mediterranean climate and a distinguished tradition of Dragon racing.

The Committee has therefore concluded that a temporary presence upon the Riviera may be tolerated, provided that standards are maintained and that Mustique’s attendance is not mistaken for an endorsement of the surrounding extravagance.

Meanwhile, her crew’s migration from Luxembourg to the South of France requires an annual exercise in logistical improvisation which would have taxed the organisational capabilities of the Great Western Railway.

How three yachtsmen contrive to convey themselves across half of Europe, at considerable expense and inconvenience, for the privilege of racing a small open yacht is a subject worthy of separate consideration.

For the present, it is sufficient to observe that convenience has never been among the principal attractions of yachting.

An unfortunate Alpine expedition

The seasonal migration between Switzerland and the Mediterranean is not entirely without incident.

On one particularly memorable occasion, Mustique found herself stranded amid a substantial snowdrift upon a closed Swiss mountain pass.

The circumstances which led a distinguished racing yacht, mounted upon her road trailer, to find herself in such an improbable position remain a matter of some discussion.

The Committee has no intention of investigating them.

It is sufficient to observe that International Dragons possess many admirable qualities. They are elegant, responsive, beautifully balanced and capable of providing some of the finest one-design racing afloat.

They are not, however, renowned for their mountaineering abilities.

No provision was made by Johan Anker for negotiating Alpine snowdrifts, and the class rules remain regrettably silent on the question of crampons.

One might reasonably ask why a party transporting a racing yacht should have attempted the passage of a snowbound Alpine road in the first place.

Such questions are invariably posed by people who have never undertaken a worthwhile adventure.

The expedition did, however, succeed in establishing a fact of some importance: while the Dragon is admirably suited to sailing beneath the Jungfrau, she is considerably less accomplished at attempting to cross the Alps herself.

Of burgees and belonging

Mustique’s rather cosmopolitan existence has naturally brought her into association with several yachting institutions of considerable distinction.

In addition to the Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club, she flies the burgees of the Royal Malta Yacht Club, Penarth Yacht Club and the Thunersee Yacht Club.

Each represents a different chapter of European yachting tradition, and each possesses qualities which the BSYC holds in the highest regard.

The Royal Malta Yacht Club brings the distinguished traditions of Mediterranean sailing and the considerable prestige of one of the world’s great offshore racing establishments.

Penarth Yacht Club provides an altogether different, but no less worthy, connection to the British sailing tradition, where the waters of the Bristol Channel have long required seamanship of a particularly robust character.

And the Thunersee Yacht Club, Mustique’s Alpine home, combines Swiss propriety with an enviable setting and a healthy appetite for competitive sailing.

The BSYC is naturally delighted to find itself in such distinguished company.

The question of precedence between these institutions has been raised, but the Committee sees little purpose in provoking an unnecessary diplomatic incident.

In any event, a yacht of Mustique’s standing ought not to be confined to a single establishment.

On matters of dress and refreshment

A yacht’s affiliations carry certain obligations ashore as well as afloat.

The Committee is pleased to report that Mustique’s company generally conducts itself in a manner befitting the establishments whose burgees she carries. Gin and tonic remains the preferred means of marking the successful conclusion of a day’s racing, irrespective of the result, while the club blazer continues to occupy its proper place in the wardrobe of the travelling yachtsman.

One unfortunate incident concerning a missing blazer button has, however, attracted a wholly disproportionate degree of attention in certain quarters. The matter, which arose shortly before an occasion requiring formal club attire, involved competing theories of responsibility, an unsuccessful search of several establishments and an eventual suggestion that the garment might be worn unfastened.

This last proposal was immediately rejected.

The offending button has yet to be recovered, and the Committee has declined to issue a statement.

A separate embarrassment arose following a particularly agreeable luncheon, when a member of the party, apparently overcome by continental habits, requested a cappuccino.

After lunch.

The silence which followed was considerable.

The waiter, being Italian, was naturally appalled. The remaining company did what it could to distance itself from the offender, while the individual concerned maintained, with increasing desperation, that he had merely asked for coffee.

The distinction was not accepted.

The incident serves as a timely reminder that travel, however broadening, must not be permitted to undermine those elementary standards upon which civilised society depends.

Espresso, naturally, remains entirely acceptable.

The case against progress

It is perhaps the greatest misfortune of the modern age that almost every institution, object and custom is now expected to undergo a process of constant improvement.

We are assured that things must become more efficient, more accessible, more inclusive, more convenient and, above all, more modern. Whether they become any better is a question seldom considered.

The results are all around us.

Yachts have become floating apartment buildings. Clubs increasingly resemble conference centres. Restaurants feel obliged to explain their philosophy before serving dinner. Proper correspondence has given way to instant messages, and the once straightforward business of ordering a drink is now liable to involve an unnecessary discussion concerning one’s preferences, sensitivities and personal journey.

Even the humble club blazer, an article of clothing perfected many generations ago, is now threatened by the widespread belief that a pair of trainers constitutes acceptable attire for almost any occasion.

The Committee regards these developments with profound disappointment.

One is tempted to conclude that civilisation reached a perfectly satisfactory state some time ago and has since been engaged in the expensive and largely unsuccessful business of correcting it.

Happily, it remains possible to escape much of this nonsense.

Luxembourg, with its quiet prosperity, established institutions and admirable preference for discretion, provides a congenial base from which to observe the decline of the wider world at a suitable distance.

Switzerland, meanwhile, offers the reassuring spectacle of a nation in which punctuality, propriety and the maintenance of established standards are still treated as virtues rather than regrettable eccentricities.

Even the Côte d’Azur, for all its modern vulgarities, retains corners of such extraordinary beauty and old-world charm that one may, with sufficient care, remain almost entirely oblivious to the present century.

Between the three, Mustique and her company have contrived to inhabit a Europe that the modern world has not yet quite succeeded in spoiling.

There remain grand hotels, distinguished yacht clubs, immaculate harbours, proper luncheon tables and terraces upon which a gin and tonic may still be enjoyed without the accompaniment of electronic music.

There are mountains to admire, seas to cross and beautiful yachts to sail.

And provided one is sufficiently selective about one’s company, it is still possible to pass an entire weekend without encountering a single fashionable opinion.

It is, upon reflection, a most agreeable existence.

A boat worth the trouble

There is a temptation, when considering Mustique’s somewhat elaborate existence, to dismiss the whole undertaking as an expensive exercise in nostalgia.

Perhaps it is.

But nostalgia is not necessarily a vice. There are occasions when looking backwards is merely the logical consequence of having examined what lies ahead.

Mustique is inconvenient to transport, requires a competent crew, demands constant attention and provides precious few of the comforts that the modern consumer has come to regard as essential.

She is also extraordinarily beautiful.

And on a summer afternoon on Lake Thun, with the Eiger, Mönch and Jungfrau rising above the water, or on a clear winter morning off Cannes, with the Mediterranean stretching away beneath her bow, the wisdom of preserving such things becomes rather obvious.

For all the absurdity involved in maintaining a racing yacht across several European countries, there remains something deeply worthwhile in doing so.

Not everything needs to become easier, larger, faster or more democratic.

Some things were conceived correctly in the first instance.

The International Dragon is one of them.

And while the rest of the world busies itself with the tiresome business of progress, Mustique will continue to sail much as Johan Anker intended nearly a century ago.

There is something profoundly comforting in that.

Long may Mustique sail.

The Cement Affair

The Cement Affair


An unfortunate misunderstanding in North Wales concerning a distinguished Luxembourgish export, the regrettable consequences of modern technology, and a diplomatic incident of quite unnecessary proportions.

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club does not ordinarily concern itself with the private social engagements of its members. What occurs beyond the confines of the Club, provided it does not bring the institution into disrepute or involve the improper use of its burgee, is generally considered a matter for the individuals concerned and their consciences.

There are, however, occasions when events of an ostensibly private nature assume such extraordinary significance that the Committee considers itself obliged to intervene.

One such occasion arose recently in North Wales, where a gathering of members became the unlikely setting for an international misunderstanding involving the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, a quantity of distinguished sparkling wine, and one of the most objectionable inventions of the modern age.

The autocorrect.

 

A most distinguished consignment

The affair began, innocently enough, with the proposed importation of a quantity of Crémant de Luxembourg.

For the uninitiated, Crémant is a sparkling wine of exceptional character, produced along the Luxembourgish banks of the Moselle, where generations of winemakers have devoted themselves to the altogether respectable pursuit of improving luncheon.

Produced by traditional methods, it possesses many of the qualities for which Champagne has become celebrated, without the tiresome necessity of announcing one’s prosperity through the price of the bottle.

It is perhaps the Grand Duchy’s most distinguished and certainly its most agreeable export.

Yet it remains curiously little known beyond Luxembourg’s borders.

This is no reflection upon its quality. The Luxembourgish have simply developed the admirable habit of consuming much of their own production, thereby sparing themselves the inconvenience of exporting their finest wines to people who may not fully appreciate them.

The Committee considers this an exceptionally enlightened arrangement.

Luxembourg is, in many respects, a remarkable country. Though lacking a coastline, a Royal Navy or any obvious opportunity for maritime conquest, it has nevertheless contrived to become a most agreeable residence for the discerning yachtsman.

Its virtues are numerous: discreet wealth, political stability, established institutions, excellent restaurants and a reassuring preference for the quiet enjoyment of life’s pleasures over their vulgar public exhibition.

The absence of a sea is, admittedly, inconvenient. But a gentleman of sufficient determination may keep his yacht elsewhere while retaining his residence in a country where the wine is excellent and society remains largely civilised.

The Committee has long maintained that proximity to salt water is not, in itself, sufficient evidence of civilisation. Numerous British seaside towns provide compelling evidence to the contrary.

It was from this unlikely bastion of the old European order that a consignment of particularly fine Moselle Crémant was selected for conveyance to North Wales.

The undertaking was not without its difficulties. Transporting sparkling wine across Western Europe requires forethought, suitable packing and a willingness to devote an entirely unreasonable amount of effort to something that might, to the uninitiated, be purchased locally.

Such people are, of course, missing the point.

One does not bring Luxembourgish Crémant to Wales because Wales lacks sparkling wine.

One brings it because the occasion deserves Luxembourgish Crémant.

 

The intervention of progress

It was during the arrangements for this distinguished consignment that the first signs of trouble emerged.

A member, intending to communicate the imminent arrival of the Crémant, dispatched a message by means of one of those small electronic devices which have so successfully displaced proper correspondence.

The communication was straightforward.

Or at least it was intended to be.

Unfortunately, the device’s autocorrect function, that most presumptuous of modern inventions, took exception to the word Crémant and substituted cement.

The consequences were immediate.

The assembled company was informed that a quantity of cement would shortly be arriving from Luxembourg.

Some confusion naturally followed.

It was suggested that the material might be intended for building works. Others enquired whether the shipment required specialist handling. One member expressed concern that the evening’s refreshments had taken an unexpectedly industrial turn.

Rather than correcting the error, the offending terminology rapidly acquired a life of its own.

By the time the bottles reached North Wales, the company had apparently arranged to spend the evening drinking imported Luxembourgish cement.

 

A diplomatic incident

The Committee does not wish to exaggerate the seriousness of the affair.

Nevertheless, describing one of the Grand Duchy’s most distinguished products as a building material constitutes a considerable affront to the national reputation.

Luxembourgish Crémant is the product of generations of viticultural knowledge, careful cultivation and painstaking cellar work.

Cement, by contrast, is generally associated with construction sites, municipal infrastructure and the more depressing consequences of town planning.

The distinction is not a minor one.

It was suggested that the Luxembourgish authorities might take a dim view of their finest sparkling wine being mistaken for materials intended for the construction of a patio with which to cover the remains of some expired pet or grandmother.

The possibility of diplomatic representations was briefly entertained.

One member proposed informing the British ambassador in Luxembourg. Another suggested referring the matter to the European Commission, whose legendary wisdom and unrivalled expertise in the regulation of absolutely everything would doubtless have proved invaluable.

Indeed, had Brussels been consulted, the affair might have been resolved through the establishment of a Directorate-General for Sparkling Wine Misidentification, the appointment of seventeen commissioners and the publication of a regulation specifying the minimum permissible distance between a bottle of Crémant and a bag of Portland cement.

Such measures would naturally have been accompanied by a comprehensive consultation on labelling, environmental impact and the rights of cement to identify as wine.

The Committee, however, was reluctant to expose so simple a matter to the full intellectual resources of the European Union.

After all, there was a party to attend.

Cooler heads prevailed, and it was determined that Anglo-Luxembourgish relations would be best served by opening another bottle.

This proved considerably more effective than any intervention from Brussels.

 

The evening’s proceedings

It should be recorded that the cement itself was received with considerable enthusiasm.

The assembled members found it exceptionally agreeable, displaying a fine mousse, lively acidity and the characteristic elegance expected of a distinguished Moselle Crémant.

Several expressed the view that it compared favourably with Champagne, an observation which the Committee regards as entirely reasonable, provided it is not made too loudly in the presence of the French.

The nomenclature, however, remained problematic.

Requests for another glass of cement became commonplace. A member was heard to enquire whether sufficient cement remained to see the company through dinner.

Another observed that he had consumed rather too much cement and would benefit from a period of inactivity.

By this stage, the affair had ceased to be a misunderstanding and become something altogether more serious.

A tradition had been established.

Among gentlemen of a certain disposition, an accidental expression, once sufficiently amusing, rapidly acquires the force of established custom. Its origins are forgotten, its usage becomes compulsory and any attempt at correction is regarded as an act of unnecessary pedantry.

Such, indeed, is the foundation upon which many of the finest British institutions have been built.

By the conclusion of the evening, the company had unanimously adopted cement as the preferred designation for Luxembourgish Crémant.

No formal vote was taken. None was necessary.

 

Of machines and their insolence

The incident raises questions of a considerably wider nature.

Autocorrect is emblematic of a particularly objectionable tendency in modern technology: the presumption that a machine, having been consulted for assistance, is thereafter entitled to substitute its own judgement for that of its owner.

A gentleman may spend a lifetime acquiring an adequate command of the English language, only to find his correspondence silently amended by a device designed in California.

The machine does not know that Crémant is a wine. It does not know that Luxembourg produces some of its finest examples. It certainly does not understand the diplomatic implications of confusing it with construction materials.

Yet it proceeds with the untroubled confidence of a European Commissioner explaining the benefits of a regulation which nobody requested and fewer still understand.

We are repeatedly assured that such innovations represent progress.

The Committee remains unconvinced.

It was once possible to compose a letter, review its contents and dispatch it with reasonable confidence that the recipient would receive precisely what the author intended.

Today, the simplest communication may be intercepted by an electronic busybody whose principal literary achievements are the unsolicited insertion of cheerful pictograms and the destruction of Anglo-Luxembourgish relations.

The modern world has developed an unfortunate obsession with making everything easier, frequently at the expense of making anything better.

It is an affliction shared by the institutions of Brussels, whose apparent conviction that every conceivable human activity might be improved through additional supervision remains one of the great mysteries of the age.

The Committee cannot help but observe that Europe managed to produce Champagne, Crémant, the International Dragon and several centuries of magnificent architecture long before anyone thought to establish a committee in Brussels to oversee them.

 

A permanent amendment to the wine list

There remained the question of how the Club ought formally to respond.

One proposal called for a categorical prohibition on autocorrect in all Club correspondence.

Another recommended the appointment of an Honorary Secretary for the Protection of Continental Wine Nomenclature.

A third suggested that members communicate exclusively by handwritten letter, a proposition which attracted considerable support until it was pointed out that several possessed handwriting of such deplorable quality that the situation might become worse.

Ultimately, the Committee adopted the more pragmatic course.

Henceforth, Luxembourgish Crémant shall be recognised within the BSYC as Cement, an expression whose accidental origins have been overtaken by the far greater authority of Club tradition.

The term shall refer exclusively to sparkling wine of suitable provenance from the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg.

It shall not be applied to inferior imitations, ordinary building materials or other sparkling wines whose origins do not justify the distinction.

The Club wine list shall be amended accordingly.

Unlike the European Union, the Committee saw no requirement for a five-year transition period, impact assessment or consultation with affected stakeholders.

Members ordering Cement may expect a properly chilled glass of Luxembourgish Crémant, served in appropriate surroundings and without unnecessary explanation.

Guests unfamiliar with the terminology may enquire as to its meaning, although the Committee would prefer that they did not.

 

A matter of civilisation

There is a pleasing irony in the fact that one of the more objectionable inventions of modern technology should inadvertently have contributed something worthwhile to the traditions of the Club.

The autocorrect, in its arrogance, attempted to amend the language of gentlemen.

The gentlemen, in their wisdom, appropriated the error and transformed it into an institution.

The distinction is an important one.

Civilisation does not advance merely because someone has invented a new machine, introduced a regulation or established another supranational committee to supervise the proper conduct of everyday life.

It advances, if at all, through good judgement, established customs, agreeable company and the preservation of things worth keeping.

Luxembourg understood this long before the arrival of the smartphone, and indeed before the arrival of the European Union, whose considerable efforts to improve the Continent have not always been greeted with universal enthusiasm.

The Grand Duchy continues to produce excellent wine, maintain its institutions and conduct its affairs with a discretion increasingly absent elsewhere.

The BSYC, for its part, will continue to uphold similar standards, notwithstanding the occasional technological interference.

And in North Wales, where this regrettable affair first unfolded, members may now raise a glass of Cement in the knowledge that they are participating in a tradition of entirely respectable origins.

The Committee considers the matter closed.

It does, however, wish to record one final observation.

While the modern world appears increasingly determined to demolish the foundations of civilisation, it is reassuring to know that the BSYC continues to take its Cement seriously.

By order of the Committee

The Singular Budleigh Salterton Yacht Club